After 14 years as Captain Baxter, the room upstairs at the St Kilda Sea Baths has a new name, a charcoal grill and an 800g rib-eye for the table.
For 14 years, Captain Baxter was where Melbourne went for birthdays, knock-offs and first dates above St Kilda Beach. On 9 October it reopened as Baxter, after a full renovation and rebrand by Melbourne Hospitality People, the family business that opened Republica downstairs in 2005.
The old place was where you went for a spritz at sunset. The new one wants you to stay for dinner. Co-owner Matt Dawson grew up in Wangaratta, did his apprenticeship in Albury, worked the Rutherglen winery circuit and cooked at Stokehouse before he opened Republica. He’s executive chef across the group, and head chef Dylan Smith runs Baxter’s kitchen day to day under him. Smith was most recently senior sous chef at Maison Bâtard, and has cooked at Doot Doot Doot at Jackalope on the Mornington Peninsula and at Relæ in Copenhagen.
“The view hasn’t changed, and neither has the feeling of walking up those stairs,” Dawson says. “What’s changed is us.”
Baxter on St Kilda Beach
- Upstairs at the St Kilda Sea Baths, 10–18 Jacka Boulevard, St Kilda
- Wednesday and Thursday: 5pm until late
- Friday to Sunday: noon until late
- Vinyl sessions: Friday and Saturday nights
Stay up to date with what’s happening in and around Melbourne here.
View this post on Instagram
The new menu
Order the crab brioche first. It comes with seaweed butter and pea furikake, the Japanese rice seasoning, and putting that on French bread at a beach bar is the clearest sign this isn’t the old kitchen.
Hot honey turns up twice. Fermented chilli honey goes over the saganaki with lemon and oregano, and hot honey goes into the Hot Honey Margarita with tequila and lime, the drink they’d like in your hand when the sun goes down.
Another must-try is the Sea Spray Sage, a martini of oyster shell gin, dry vermouth, sage and saline: it’s the most St Kilda drink on the list. The wine list does exactly what a sunset bar needs to. The whites by the glass include a Yarra Valley chardonnay, an Eden Valley riesling and a Petit Chablis, and the reds cover pinot noir from the Yarra Valley and the Mornington Peninsula, shiraz from Heathcote and the Barossa, and a Margaret River cabernet.
The menu runs in three stages. Start with Sydney rock oysters, move through small plates to share, then let the charcoal grill finish the job: baby barramundi fillets, or an 800g rib-eye if the whole table is committed.
The wagyu skewers are a small plate worth fighting the table for, served with an eye-opening beer mustard and pickled cucumber.
For a smaller main than than the rib-eye, the 250g MB4+ eye fillet, with peppercorn sauce and smoked onions, is delectable. Get the skin-on fries on the side and you’ve got steak frites with Port Phillip Bay in the background.
View this post on Instagram
Leave room for the chocolate marquise, made with vanilla and elderflower and served with coffee, white chocolate and malt ice cream. Best finished on a Montenegro, the Bologna amaro that’s been made to the same recipe since 1885. It isn’t on the printed drinks list, but it’s behind the bar.
From baths to Baxter
Then there’s the room, which does half the work before anything lands. The water side is glass from floor to ceiling, Port Phillip Bay fills nearly the entire wall, and at sunset the light comes straight across the water into the dining room.
Needless to say, book for sunset.
People have been coming to this stretch of sand to get in the water for more than 170 years. At one point six separate bathing complexes lined the shore between Catani Gardens and Brookes Jetty.
Baxter’s building replaced the 1931 baths in the Spanish Mission style, with domed towers, separate enclosures for men and women, hot sea baths, a gym, cafes and a nightclub. Most of it came down in 1995, but the palatial arcading, sea baths and two of the towers remain.
It’s a beautiful building, in a beautiful location.
A suburb in flux
Baxter isn’t the only room on Jacka Boulevard starting over. At number 30, the van Haandel family sold Stokehouse, which they’d run since 1990, to Andrew McConnell and Jo McGann’s Trader House this year.
Trader House now runs Stokehouse upstairs and Marea Beach House & Bar downstairs, which also grills its octopus.
The crowds are already here. St Kilda Festival expected more than 350,000 people in the suburb across two days in February, and St Kilda has been Victoria’s first official live music precinct since June 2023.
Baxter keeps its music to vinyl DJs in the dining room, and the bands play downstairs at Republica.
Dawson reckons the people who’ve been climbing those stairs for the past decade have grown up, and Baxter is built for who they are now. Start with the crab brioche.