One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest at the Athenaeum is darkly funny and properly tense
Subscribe
X

Get the latest from Beat

"*" indicates required fields

19.11.2026

One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest at the Athenaeum is darkly funny and properly tense

One Flew over the cuckoo's nest
Credit: Eugene Hyland
words by Bryget Chrisfield

One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest turns the spotlight on Chief Bromden, with Jason Donovan and Nadine Garner leading a tense Athenaeum cast.

Dale Wasserman’s stage adaptation of One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest – which predates the Jack Nicholson-starring film version – stays truer to Ken Kesey’s original novel (1962), in which Chief Bromden is more central to the storyline, and this shift in perspective changes the way audience members feel during familiar scenes.

The morbidly charged frisson between Randle P. McMurphy (Jason Donovan) and Nurse Ratched (Nadine Garner) remains a focal point, but we find ourselves looking for, and checking up on, the Chief throughout.

One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest

  • Where: Athenaeum Theatre
  • When: Now, until December 20
  • Tickets and information here

Stay up to date with what’s happening in and around Melbourne here. 

All of the accolades to Canadian actor Jeremy Proulx (Chief Bromden). His facial tics never falter and we root for this gentle giant, who’s been made to feel small and incapable as he struggles to maintain cultural pride within “the nationwide Combine”.

Proulx’s Chief Bromden gradually transforms from twitching and obedient – pretending to be a deaf non-speaker – into a warrior-in-training, finding his true voice.

His expressive eyes convey a spectrum of emotions and Proulx’s physicality changes incrementally as his character regains confidence and composure.

Our guts churn from empathetic stress during Proulx’s final scenes.

Kohan Van Sambeek’s original music reflects Chief Bromden’s inner world, while his hallucinations and memories are brought to brilliant life by lighting designer Niklas Pajanti’s swirling visuals.

Director Roger Hodgman does an excellent job of balancing simmering tension with dark humour – we’re almost too scared to laugh at times.

Donovan’s McMurphy is charismatic, curious, cheeky, good-intentioned and loyal to a fault.

He chooses to stay in the institution, letting many opportunities to escape pass him by.

Dedicating his performances of this play to Terence Donovan – his father, an esteemed actor, who passed away earlier this year – Jason notes in the program: “I so wish he could have been here to see me take on this role.”

Garner’s Ratched genuinely believes she’s doing good. As the action unfolds, we notice moral grey areas that challenge our beliefs. Her performance is nuanced – we see momentary flashes of fear and self-doubt – and Garner has Ratched’s cruel smile – which never reaches her eyes – down pat.

Even though his character has few lines, John Xintavelonis excels as Martini. The other ‘patients’ – including Martin Blum (Scanlon), Gyton Grantley (Cheswick), David James (Harding), Daniel R Nixon (Billy Bibbit) and Chris Connelly (Ruckley/Aide Turkle) – are also exceptional, playing their roles with maximum commitment.

Set designer Richard Roberts followed the playwright’s instructions, creating what resembles an actual day room in a mental asylum somewhere in America in the late ’60s/early ’70s.

One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest explores power and control within institutions that are supposed to keep us safe, freedom as an essential human right and how shame, fear and social pressure traps individuals in submission and silence. It’s chilling stuff. We’ll be pondering the uncomfortable truths this play exposes long after the final curtain.

One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest plays at the Athenaeum until 20 December

I haven’t changed any wording. The only fix worth making is the third paragraph, which says Chief Romden instead of Chief Bromden.

For more information, head here.